How Can I Make My Madison, WI Home Insurance Cheaper

Gavop shows you how to buy homeowners insurance in Madison, WI by estimating coverage, choosing the right deductible, contacting the best agents, understanding claim requirements, comparing cheap rates, using discount options and reading reviews.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Are you a home owner?
Yes No
Currently Insured?
Yes No


Select the Suitable Coverage Value for your Madison, WI Home | Back to Top

Bedrooms Average Home Value Estimated Replacement Value Recommended Home Insurance Coverage
1 Bedroom $71,000 $70,000 $75,000-$100,000
2 Bedroom $157,000 $140,000 $125,000-$150,000
3 Bedroom $167,000 $130,000 $150,000-$175,000
4 Bedroom $256,000 $220,000 $200,000-$250,000
5 Bedroom $500,500 $460,000 $400,000-$500,000

Estimate your Savings with Home Insurance Discounts in Madison, WI | Back to Top

Type Discount ($) Premium After Discount ($)
Multipolicy Discount -$110 $624
Superior Protection Discount -$66 $668
Fire & Security Discount -$81 $654
Hail Resistant Roof Discount -$22 $712
Newly Constructed Home Discount -$206 $529

Choose your Madison, WI Home Insurance Coverage for your Specific Claim Requirement | Back to Top

Claim Type Average Claim Cost
General Claims
Water Damage $5,975
Physical Damage $2,344
Hail Damage $4,900
Wind Damage $6,496
Expensive Claims
Fire $42,442
Smoke $16,051

Identify Top Home Insurance Agents near Madison, WI | Back to Top

Home Insurance Company Madison, WI Homeowners Insurance Agency Madison, WI Address Popularity Score Distance from Madison (miles)
Travelers Insurance Service Center 117 Oakridge Ct., Watertown, WI, 53094
37.7
Travelers Neckerman Insurance 6200 Mineral Point Rd, Madison, WI, 53705
3.4
GEICO Brian Schroeder 2001 West Beltline Highway Suite 100, Madison, WI, 53713
3.8
State Farm Melissa Eckstrom 1771 Thierer Rd, Madison, WI, 53704-3721
6.4
Farmers Debra Armstrong 621 N Sherman Ave Ste B16, Madison, WI, 53704
3.6
State Farm Aaron Perry 2605 Monroe St, Madison, WI, 53711-1801
2.1
Liberty Mutual Nicholas Kohal 708 Heartland Trail Ste 1800, Madison, WI, 53717
5.3
Erie Bryan Holder Insurance Agency Llc 2316 Mineral Point Avenue Suite 104, Janesville, WI, 53548
33.8
State Farm Terry Sminchak 1116 Cranston Rd, Beloit, WI, 53511-2533
43.6
State Farm Michael Wegner 6514 Odana Road, Madison, WI, 53719-1165
3.9

Compare Rates for Madison, WI Home Insurance Providers | Back to Top

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Place Typical Home Value Typical Home Insurance Costs 25th Percentile 75th Percentile Potential Savings & Difference between 25th & 75th Percentile
Wisconsin $169,300 $685 $470 $970 $500
Dane County, WI $242,700 $754 $550 $1,080 $530
Madison, WI $223,300 $734 $510 $1,040 $530
Westport, WI $287,500 $823 $550 $1,160 $610
Monona, WI $246,400 $656 $480 $940 $460
Fulton, WI $188,500 $715 $520 $990 $470
Fall River, WI $166,500 $681 $480 $960 $480
Jordan, WI $175,000 $695 $470 $970 $500
Lewiston, WI $161,200 $672 $490 $920 $430
Spring Grove, WI $195,700 $724 $510 $1,000 $490
Randolph, WI $108,500 $550 $400 $760 $360
Avoca, WI $72,200 $425 $310 $600 $290
Rockton, IL $142,200 $647 $460 $920 $460

Research Home Insurance Companies Reviews in Madison, WI Before Buying | Back to Top

Share a review on your home insurance company


Grange Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

Date: September 29, 2018    Age: 20 to 29    Gender: Female    Marital Status: Married

Website/App
I have only used the website. It is easy to use and provides me with all of the information I need about my insurance coverage. I am completely satisfied with this company which I just started with last year and I will renew again with in September.

Date: September 18, 2018    Age: 20 to 29    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Unmarried

Customer Service
I have gone through a broker for the most part. There was an issue getting my bank to pay out of my escrow account, but we got that resolved very quickly and I was happy with the way it was handled.

Date: August 27, 2018    Age: 50 to 59    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Married

Policy Offerings
My dwelling and garage are covered. I also have loss of use coverage. There is medical coverage for someone injured on the property.


Date: August 24, 2018    Age: 20 to 29    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Unmarried

Website/App
The interface on the website is simple for me to use. While it is not aesthetically glamorous it serves the purpose and is extremely easy to navigate. You can file a claim right online.

Date: August 08, 2018    Age: 20 to 29    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Married

Customer Service
I have had to use them twice in the 10 years I have had the policy and both times it has been easy to handle. They were extremely nice and professional. They set appointments for adjusters and they were always on time and treatment me with respect. I experienced no resistance to them paying either claim.

Date: August 01, 2018    Age: 30 to 39    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Married

Policy Offerings
All of my belongings in the house are covered as well as the dwelling and all structures on the property. There is coverage for medical expenses in the event anyone gets hurt.


Date: July 29, 2018    Age: 20 to 29    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Married

Premium
My premiums work well for me and I am very happy with this company. I have not had any claims yet, so I don't know how well they would do if I did have a claim.

Date: May 03, 2018    Age: 20 to 29    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Married

Communication
All communication and information have been timely and any questions or concerns have been quickly resolved. I am very happy with everything so far.

Date: November 19, 2017    Age: 20 to 29    Gender: Female    Marital Status: Married

Communication
They have always responded to any inquiry with quickness and accuracy. Everyone I have ever spoken with treats me with respect and understands that I am their customer.

Date: November 18, 2017    Age: 30 to 39    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Unmarried

Premium
It is a very competitive rate with other companies. I have compared recently with many companies including USAA, whom I carry my vehicle insurance with, and there is little or no savings. There are not enough savings to make me want to change companies at this time.

Farm Bureau Home Insurance Reviews

Date: January 03, 2020    Age: 20 to 29    Gender: Female    Marital Status: Unmarried

Premium
I have a 1,000 deductible and I have great coverage for what I need. It covers my house as well as outbuildings and animals.

Date: September 24, 2018    Age: 50 to 59    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Married

Website/App
They do not have an app or website I can use. This is a drawback but their service more than makes up for this.

Date: September 16, 2018    Age: 30 to 39    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Married

Policy Offerings
They are always there for me when I need them. I have never had an issue where my agent did not return my call immediately


Date: August 20, 2018    Age: 30 to 39    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Married

Customer Service
The service is excellent. If it decreases it would give me a reason to leave the company but that has not happened yet.

Date: August 15, 2018    Age: 30 to 39    Gender: Female    Marital Status: Unmarried

Communication
They have amazing customer service. An agent even assisted me over the weekend on a new vehicle purchase recently.

Date: August 04, 2018    Age: 30 to 39    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Unmarried

Premium
I have not compared premiums as my service has been so great. I am guessing I am paying a little more but the people that work there make up for the extra bit in premium

State Farm Home Insurance Reviews

Date: September 11, 2019    Age: 50 to 59    Gender: Female    Marital Status: Unmarried

Customer Service
I would rate them as a 4. They are polite, responsive and very good listeners. On the two occasions I have had to file claims, for the most part the claims have been issue free. I would like them to be more proactive

Date: September 21, 2018    Age: 20 to 29    Gender: Female    Marital Status: Unmarried

Policy Offerings
My insurance is covering everything other than flooding and other structures. The most common items along with medical and living expenses are also included in the coverage.


Date: September 17, 2018    Age: 40 to 49    Gender: Female    Marital Status: Married

Premium
I've had other insurance companies before and the premium that I had to pay was much higher than the current one. It is a competitive premium and affordable.

Date: September 04, 2018    Age: 30 to 39    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Unmarried

Website/App
The company's website is very helpful offering all the needed information from "request of the quote" to 24 Hours Emergency phone number. It is very easy to navigate and self-explanatory.

Date: August 12, 2018    Age: 20 to 29    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Married

Communication
The calls and in-person interaction with this company were great. I've had a very pleasant experience going there when I switched from my previous insurer, and the representative was very knowledgeable and polite.

Date: November 19, 2017    Age: 50 to 59    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Unmarried

Customer Service
Every call made with different questions to my current insurance company where answered immediately and professionally without being placed on hold or having to argue to obtain what I needed.

Progressive Home Insurance Reviews

Date: October 08, 2019    Age: 20 to 29    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Unmarried

Customer Service
We haven't ever had to use our home insurance but as far as we know it has been a smooth experience, but it will only be truly tested when we need to use the insurance.

Date: May 23, 2019    Age: 40 to 49    Gender: Married    Marital Status: Male

Premium
I don't know enough about other home or renter insurance companies to make a real assessment here, I assume the premium and deductible are fairly average.

Date: February 09, 2019    Age: 40 to 49    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Married

Policy Offerings
I'm satisfied. They offer all the coverage I need to for my mortgage and I don't live an area with special needs (flood insurance, etc.).


Allstate Home Insurance Reviews

Date: December 26, 2019    Age: 20 to 29    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Unmarried

Premium
The rate and deductible are cheap compared to most companies in the area, and given the reputation of Allstate, I was comfortable that the low rate would still cover everything i wanted and needed.

Date: August 16, 2019    Age: 30 to 39    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Married

Customer Service
I am more than happy with the level of customer service I get from allstate. Many times the app is enough to answer my questions but my agent is always there to talk to me as well if I need it.

West Bend Mutual Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

Date: December 29, 2018    Age: 30 to 39    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Married

Customer Service
My insurance company's customer service is adequate. Fortunately, I have never had to file a claim but I have never had any issues with sales or billing. I had an insurance review that helped lower my coverage and streamline my needs. The service was excellent. I also receive a cash back payment for not having any claims. Billing is a little difficult because the online payment platform isn't particularly user friendly.

Wisconsin Mutual Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

Date: January 01, 2019    Age: 30 to 39    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Unmarried

Premium
The premium is affordable and the deductible is good. I pay quarterly and It is very convenient for me. I am satisfied with the price.

Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Reviews

Date: December 21, 2019    Age: 30 to 39    Gender: Female    Marital Status: Unmarried

Premium
The monthly premium is so reasonable, but more importantly, the coverage is very comprehensive. My agent made sure to find a policy that worked for maximum coverage on my budget.

Nationwide Home Insurance Reviews

Date: November 17, 2018    Age: 40 to 49    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Married

Customer Service
I would rate them as a 4. I haven't had to really contact them much recently, but when I purchased my home I had some interaction with them. They were pretty quick to address any concerns that I had.

Erie Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

Date: October 18, 2019    Age: 30 to 39    Gender: Male    Marital Status: Married

Customer Service
Erie has being my first and only insurance company and I love all their customer's service because it is very much favourable for me and my family

GEICO Home Insurance Reviews

Date: December 02, 2018    Age: 30 to 39    Gender: Female    Marital Status: Unmarried

Premium
I dont remember all the details from the policy. I do know that it is a decent amount of all the details. and I do pay a pretty penny for all of it.

Lenox Mutual Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

Date: November 01, 2018    Age: 40 to 49    Gender: Female    Marital Status: Married

Policy Offerings
Fire, home appliances, theft insurance is insired in our home policy.


Safeco Insurance Home Insurance Reviews

8 Ways to Get Discounts on Homeowners Insurance in Madison, WI

What Makes Your Madison, WI Home Insurance Cheap or Expensive