How Can I Make My Butler County, PA Home Insurance Cheaper

Gavop shows you how to buy homeowners insurance in Butler County, PA by estimating coverage, choosing the right deductible, contacting the best agents, understanding claim requirements, comparing cheap rates, using discount options and reading reviews.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Are you a home owner?
Yes No
Currently Insured?
Yes No


Select the Suitable Coverage Value for your Butler County, PA Home | Back to Top

Bedrooms Average Home Value Estimated Replacement Value Recommended Home Insurance Coverage
1 Bedroom $71,000 $60,000 $50,000-$75,000
2 Bedroom $164,000 $130,000 $175,000-$200,000
3 Bedroom $242,000 $220,000 $175,000-$200,000
4 Bedroom $335,000 $270,000 $350,000-$400,000
5 Bedroom $296,500 $240,000 $300,000-$350,000

Estimate your Savings with Home Insurance Discounts in Butler County, PA | Back to Top

Type Discount ($) Premium After Discount ($)
Multipolicy Discount -$136 $621
Superior Protection Discount -$68 $689
Fire & Security Discount -$83 $674
Hail Resistant Roof Discount -$23 $735
Newly Constructed Home Discount -$205 $553

Choose the Right Deductible for your Butler County, PA Home | Back to Top

Low Deductible ($500) High Deductible ($2500)
Place Example Claim Amount Yearly Premium Total Yearly Cost Yearly Premium Total Yearly Cost Net Savings for High Deductible Plan
Butler County $1,500 $748 $2,248 $544 $2,044 $205
Butler County, PA $1,500 $748 $2,248 $544 $2,044 $205
Butler, PA $500 $672 $1,172 $488 $988 $184
Gilpin, PA $700 $650 $1,350 $472 $1,172 $178
Harmar, PA $300 $621 $921 $452 $752 $170
Orchard Hills, PA $2,500 $558 $3,058 $406 $2,906 $153
Ohioville, PA $100 $673 $773 $489 $589 $184
Monroeville, PA $700 $627 $1,327 $455 $1,155 $171
Clark, PA $400 $713 $1,113 $518 $918 $195
West Elizabeth, PA $700 $478 $1,178 $348 $1,048 $131
Langeloth, PA $200 $539 $739 $392 $592 $147
Herminie, PA $2,000 $520 $2,520 $378 $2,378 $142

Identify Top Home Insurance Agents near Butler County, PA | Back to Top

Home Insurance Company Butler County, PA Homeowners Insurance Agency Butler County, PA Address Popularity Score Distance from Butler County (miles)
State Farm Chrissy Forster 602 Evans City Road Suite 102, Butler, PA, 16001-8728
4.7
State Farm Brian Winfield 550 Route 30, Irwin, PA, 15642
43.7
State Farm Gwen Sciullo 122 Point Plz, Butler, PA, 16001-2540
3.1
Farmers Western Pa Insured Professionals 665 Evans City Rd, Butler, PA, 16001
5.2
Erie Minich Insurance Agency Llc 230 Mercer Street, Butler, PA, 16001
3.4
Erie Eshenbaugh Insurance Llc 1212 W Sunbury Road, West Sunbury, PA, 16061
5.9
Allstate Ryan Mackey 2340 Warren Rd Ste 201, Indiana, PA, 15701
43.7
Allstate Independent Associates Of Pa 1252 W Sunbury Rd Po Box 250, West Sunbury, PA, 16061
6.2
Erie John E Hollock 506 N Main Street, Butler, PA, 16001
3.5
Erie Hritsko Insurance Llc 102 W Pike Street Suite 202, Houston, PA, 15342
48.4

Compare Rates for Butler County, PA Home Insurance Providers | Back to Top

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

Place Typical Home Value Typical Home Insurance Costs 25th Percentile 75th Percentile Potential Savings & Difference between 25th & 75th Percentile
Pennsylvania $170,500 $745 $530 $1,060 $530
Butler County, PA $190,000 $758 $550 $1,050 $500
Butler County, PA $190,000 $758 $550 $1,080 $530
Butler, PA $163,100 $680 $460 $970 $510
Gilpin, PA $127,300 $658 $440 $910 $470
Harmar, PA $114,200 $629 $420 $890 $470
Orchard Hills, PA $88,500 $565 $410 $780 $370
Ohioville, PA $138,100 $681 $480 $970 $490
Monroeville, PA $138,400 $634 $460 $870 $410
Clark, PA $158,500 $722 $490 $990 $500
West Elizabeth, PA $60,600 $484 $340 $660 $320
Langeloth, PA $81,600 $546 $370 $780 $410
Herminie, PA $74,500 $526 $380 $740 $360

8 Ways to Get Discounts on Homeowners Insurance in Butler County, PA

What Makes Your Butler County, PA Home Insurance Cheap or Expensive